
257 Sugarloaf Street

257 Sugarloaf Street



See all 45 photosProperty history
- $599,900TerminatedList: 2025-05-23|End: 2025-07-08|46 daysX12171233
- $609,900TerminatedList: 2025-04-29|End: 2025-05-26|27 daysX12111371
- $639,900TerminatedList: 2025-03-26|End: 2025-04-30|35 daysX12044116
- $699,900TerminatedList: 2024-11-18|End: 2025-03-26|128 daysX10429284
Facts and features
- BasementFull
- Age of home51–99 years
- Price per sq ft~$366
- Water, sewerMunicipal
The homeDetached, 2-storey, Age 51–99 years
- Type: Detached
- Style: 2-storey
- Age: 51–99 years
- Living space: 1,500–2,000 sq ft
- Basement: Full
- Waterfront: None
InsideSump pump, Rooms above ground 8, Bedrooms 4
- Features: Sump pump
- Rooms above ground: 8
- Bedrooms: 4
- Bathrooms: 1
- Kitchens: 1
- Family room: Yes
Outside and lotStucco (plaster), Asphalt shingle, Poured concrete
- Exterior: Stucco (plaster)
- Roof: Asphalt shingle
- Foundation: Poured concrete
- Size: 59.51 × 160 ft
- Shape: Rectangular
- Zoning: R2
Parking1 Garage, Detached, Private double
- Spaces: 1 Garage
- Garage: Detached
- Driveway: Private double
Heating, water and powerWater, gas, Window unit(s), Municipal water
- Heating: Water, gas
- Cooling: Window unit(s)
- Water: Municipal water
- Sewer: Municipal sewer
- Natural gas: Yes
- Hydro: Yes
- Cable: Yes
- Telephone: Yes
Costs and taxesTaxes $3,771 a year, HST included in the price
- Taxes, 2024: $3,771 a year
- HST: HST included in the price
Listing detailsX12044116, Terminated, Mar 26, 2025
- MLS® number: X12044116
- Status: Terminated
- Listed on: Mar 26, 2025
- Days on market: 35
- Updated: Apr 30, 2025
- Possession: Immediate
- Occupied by: Vacant
- Listing brokerage: RE/MAX NIAGARA REALTY LTD, BROKERAGE
About this home
257 Sugarloaf Street, Port Colborne (Sugarloaf), ON L3K 2P1
*The Old Mill House* Discover timeless charm in an unbeatable location! Situated directly across from Lake Erie, HH Knoll Park, and the picturesque Sugarloaf Marina, this well-maintained classic home is just a short stroll to Historic West Street and the vibrant heart of downtown. Renowned for its stunning curb appeal and inviting front porch, this home showcases its rich character through beautifully preserved details like wood doors, trim, baseboards, and flooring. The spacious living room is bathed in natural light from large paned windows during the day, complemented by cozy pot lights in the evening. A formal dining room, accessed through double French doors, leads to a modernized kitchen featuring a breakfast bar and convenient access to the backyard. The elegant wood staircase ascends to four generously sized bedrooms, offering plenty of space for family and guests. With over 1,600 sq. ft. of living space, the property also includes an unfinished attic, accessible by staircase, presenting exciting potential for additional living or recreational space. Nestled on a 160 deep lot, the home boasts landscaped gardens, interlock pathways, and a spacious backyard shaded by mature trees. The rear Breakwater Laneway leads to a one-car garage, with parking access from both Steele Street and Isabel Street. Recent updates include a new roof in 2023, ensuring peace of mind for years to come. Dont miss your chance to own this stunning piece of history in a prime lakeside setting!
Ask about this home
A HOMEH agent will answer your questions about this home.
Around this home
Daily convenience, out of 100, from the distances below
Schools nearby
School rating, out of 10.
Helpful calculators
Your HOMEH agent

"Priced 19% over the Hestimate. I would see it this week."