
258 Henrietta Street

258 Henrietta Street
Property history
- $799,000ExpiredList: 2026-07-06|End: 2026-10-06|92 daysX13530106
- $799,000TerminatedList: 2026-05-20|End: 2026-07-02|43 daysX13151128
- $799,000TerminatedList: 2026-03-20|End: 2026-05-08|49 daysX12905506
- $849,000TerminatedList: 2025-09-11|End: 2025-12-03|83 daysX12398555
- $799,000TerminatedList: 2025-07-24|End: 2025-09-10|48 daysX12313328
- $950,000TerminatedList: 2025-04-14|End: 2025-07-09|86 daysX12084995
Facts and features
- BasementNone
- Price per sq ft~$246
- Water, sewerMunicipal
- HeatingOther
- 5 kitchens
The homeMultiplex, 2-storey, 3,000–3,500 sq ft
- Type: Multiplex
- Style: 2-storey
- Living space: 3,000–3,500 sq ft
- Basement: None
InsideWater heater, Smoke detector, Rooms above ground 13
- Features: Water heater
- Security: Smoke detector
- Rooms above ground: 13
- Bedrooms: 13
- Bathrooms: 5
- Kitchens: 5
- Family room: Yes
Outside and lotVinyl siding, Unknown, Unknown
- Exterior: Vinyl siding
- Roof: Unknown
- Foundation: Unknown
- Other structures: Other
- Size: 82 × 233 ft
Parking8 Parking
- Spaces: 8 Parking
Heating, water and powerOther, gas, Municipal water, Municipal sewer
- Heating: Other, gas
- Water: Municipal water
- Sewer: Municipal sewer
Costs and taxesTaxes $5,637 a year, HST included in the price
- Taxes, 2025: $5,637 a year
- HST: HST included in the price
NearbyOther
- Close to: Other
Listing detailsX13151128, Terminated, May 20, 2026
- MLS® number: X13151128
- Status: Terminated
- Listed on: May 20, 2026
- Days on market: 43
- Updated: Jul 2, 2026
- Possession: Flexible
- Occupied by: Tenant
- Listing brokerage: RE/MAX REALTY SPECIALISTS INC.
About this home
258 Henrietta Street, Fort Erie (Central), ON L2A 2K7
Attention Investors! Exceptional turnkey 5-Plex offering potential strong, stable rental income on a massive 82 ft x 233 ft lot in the growing community of Fort Erie. Welcome to 258 Henrietta Street - a rare opportunity to own a fully rentable multi-residential property with excellent cash-flow potential and future upside. This well-maintained investment property features 5 self-contained units across two separate buildings. The front building includes 2 spacious residential units, while the rear building offers 3 updated units, including three desirable 2-bedroom layouts. In total, the property boasts 13 bedrooms, making it an attractive option for investors seeking strong rental performance and long-term appreciation. Each unit is separately metered for hydro and gas, with tenants paying their own utilities - a major advantage for reducing operating expenses and maximizing net income. Recent improvements include updated shingles on both buildings, adding to the property's overall durability and ease of ownership. Ideally situated near schools, shopping, public transit, the Niagara River, the U.S. border, and a nearby college. The oversized lot also presents potential future development or value-add opportunities, subject to buyer due diligence and municipal approvals. A solid addition to any real estate portfolio with reliable income, strong tenant appeal, and long-term growth potential.
Ask about this home
A HOMEH agent will answer your questions about this home.
Around this home
Daily convenience, out of 100, from the distances below
Schools nearby
School rating, out of 10.
Helpful calculators
Your HOMEH agent

"Priced 26% over the Hestimate. I would see it this week."