Listed for:Listed Jul 28, 2026
$499,900

10 & 11 Methodist Island

Tay (Port McNicoll), ON L0K 1R0

Detached House For Sale
Down Payment AssistanceGet Best Mortgage Rates

Sale & Price History for 10 & 11 Methodist Island, Tay, Port McNicoll

No listing history available

Real estate boards require you to or to see the full details of this property.

*Sold prices and complete sale & price history are regulated data. Under the Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002 (TRESA) and the rules of the Real Estate Council of Ontario (RECO), and pursuant to the Multiple Listing Service® rules of the Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA) and the Toronto Regional Real Estate Board (TRREB), this information may be shown only to registered users who have agreed to the applicable terms of use (a Virtual Office Website, or "VOW," arrangement). HOMEH Inc., Brokerage therefore provides it to signed-in members only. Creating an account is free and takes under a minute.

About 10 & 11 Methodist Island, Tay, Port McNicoll

Summarized Description

  • Unique private island location with boat access
  • Vaulted ceilings and open concept design
  • Cozy loft overlooking living areas
  • Spacious deck for family gatherings
  • Wood stove for cozy evenings
  • Access to pristine 30,000 Islands
  • Ideal for creating lasting family traditions
  • Surrounded by nature and scenic views

Welcome to the kind of cottage where family traditions begin and are passed down for generations. A place where mornings start with coffee on the deck as the lake comes to life, children spend the afternoons catching frogs and turtles along the shoreline, swimming until the sun begins to set, and evenings end around the fire with songs, stories, s'mores, and laughter that the family will talk about for years to come. Inside captures everything you love about Georgian Bay living. Vaulted ceilings and a bright open concept design create a warm, inviting space where everyone naturally gathers, while the cozy loft overlooks the kitchen, dining, and living areas, ensuring no one ever misses a moment. The wood stove adds the perfect touch for cool evenings after a day spent exploring the water. Outside, life slows down exactly as it should. The spacious deck is made for family dinners under the open sky, the yard is ready for games that become annual traditions, and the fire pit is where unforgettable stories are shared. Here, you'll trade busy schedules for barefoot summers, glowing sunsets, and the simple joy of watching your children grow up surrounded by nature instead of screens. Methodist Island is located at the gateway to the world famous 30,000 Islands where you can experience some of the finest freshwater boating in the world. Spend your days discovering hidden coves, quiet bays, and endless shoreline, or cruise to waterfront restaurants in Midland, Penetanguishene, Honey Harbour, and Parry Sound. Accessible only by boat, the island offers the rare gift of true privacy while remaining just a five minute ride from Victoria Harbour for groceries, the LCBO, and everyday conveniences. This isn't simply a cottage. It's where birthdays are celebrated, fish stories grow bigger every year, kids become parents, and traditions live long after the summer ends. It's a place where life slows down, families reconnect, and memories last forever.

Key Facts & Features

Property Costs

Annual Property Tax Amount
$3,425
Land Transfer Tax Fee
$6,473

Basement Type
None

Interior Features

Interior Extras
Primary Bedroom - Main Floor
View
Water, Trees/Woods
Fireplace/Stove
Yes
Fireplace Features
Wood Stove
Elevator
No

Exterior Features

Exterior Extras
Deck, Privacy
Pool
None
Property Features
Beach, Clear View, Island, Lake/Pond, Marina, Waterfront
Other Structures
Aux Residences, Garden Shed

Building

Building Type
Detached
Building Style
Bungalow-Raised
Approx Age
31-50

Construction

Exterior Finish
Wood
Roof
Metal
Foundation Details
Piers
Special Designation
Unknown

Lot

Lot Front
200.60 ft
Lot Depth
144.42 ft
Lot Size
1.03

Inclusions

Inclusions
All existing appliances, most furniture, basement tools and boat. All to be accepted as is

Parking & Garages

Garage Type
None
Garage Spaces
0
Parking Spaces
0
Total Garage And Parking Spaces
0

Heating & Cooling

Heat Source
Electric
Heat Type
Baseboard
Air Conditioning
Window Unit(s)
Water
Other
Sewers
Septic
Hydro
Yes

Bedrooms
4
Washrooms
1
Kitchens
1

Room sizes

  • Kitchen—
    Main level, Laminate, Centre Island, W/O To Deck
  • Bathroom—
    Main level
  • Bedroom—
    Main level, Laminate
  • Living Room—
    Main level, Laminate, Wood Stove
  • Bedroom 3—
    Main level, Laminate
  • Dining Room—
    Main level, Laminate, W/O To Deck
  • Bedroom 2—
    Main level, Laminate
  • Loft—
    Upper level, Laminate

Washrooms

  • 4-piece, Main

Municipality
Tay
Neighbourhood
Port McNicoll
Main cross streets
Hwy 12 and William St.
Zoning
RS-4
Directions
Boat access
Waterfront
Direct

MLS® number
S13611936
Data source
Toronto Regional Real Estate Board
Listed on
2026-07-28
Updated on
2026-08-07
Days on market
79 days
Possession type
Flexible
Co-op commission
4%+HST
Seller
Listed by
Keller Williams Home Group Realty

Home Market Value

Current home valuation for 10 & 11 Methodist Island, Tay, Port McNicoll, Tay, ON. Listed for $499,900

HOMEH Estimate

?

$371,250

Estimated Sales Range

?

$330,000 - $507,389

HOMEH Estimate for 10 & 11 Methodist Island, Tay, Port McNicoll

Calculated with a real agent's CMA method — 45+ years of experience, codified. Not an AI guess.

$371,250Low confidence
Based on 10 comparable properties
+ $128,650 (35%) above our estimate
See the full analysisFree Every recent nearby sale behind this number
Approximate location — within this block
Get Directions

Mortgage Payment Calculator

Compare up to 4 down payment scenarios

$
Tay, ON
Minimum Down Payment Required:5.0%

5% of purchase price for homes $500K or less

Minimum down payment

$24,995

Scenario 1 Scenario 2 Scenario 3 Scenario 4
−Down payment
%
$
%
$
%
$
%
$
+CMHC insurance
$18,996$13,947$11,898$0
=Total mortgage
$493,901$463,857$436,813$399,920
Amortization
Mortgage rate
%
%
%
%
Payment frequency
=Mortgage payment
$2,411monthly$2,265monthly$2,133monthly$1,953monthly
Are you a first time home buyer?

Land Transfer Tax

Provincial

$6,473

Total Land Transfer Tax

$6,473

Around this home

0/100Almost All Errands Require a Car
0/100Minimal Transit
0/100Not rated
Loading map...

No schools found nearby

Ask HOMEH

New!
H

Hi there!

👋

Text or call (416) 301-9001

Recommended for you

Based on homes you've looked at.

No recommended properties found.

Nearby similar homes

No nearby properties found.