Real Estate for Sale in Port McNicoll, Tay, ON
Loading homes in Port McNicoll…
No listings match these filters in this area.
Try zooming out or widening your filters.
Neighbourhood in Tay
Port McNicoll
Port McNicoll is a small neighbourhood in Tay, Ontario. It offers a quiet lifestyle with close-knit community feel.
Tay, Ontario
© Wikimedia Commons contributors (CC BY-SA)
At a glance
Listed 1 day ago
480 Broderick Street
Tay (Port McNicoll), ON L0K 1R0
DetachedFor Sale
Listed 2 days ago
244/250 Dignard Avenue
Tay (Port McNicoll), ON L0K 1R0
DetachedFor Sale
Listed 6 days ago
7 Dock Lane
Tay (Port McNicoll), ON L0K 1R0
DetachedFor Sale
Listed 14 days ago
5 Easton Avenue
Tay (Port McNicoll), ON L0K 1R0
DetachedFor Sale
What it costsAffordability
Median asking price
$550,000
In Port McNicoll
$550,000
In Tay
$639,900
In Ontario
$718,000
Median monthly rent
$2,800/mo
In Port McNicoll
$2,800
In Tay
$2,200
In Ontario
$2,500
$764
Per square foot
≈ 16.4 years
Of rent to match the purchase price
On the marketMarket snapshot
For sale
37
Median $550,000
Houses 37
For rent
1
Median $2,800
Houses 1
Recently sold
Sign in to see sold data
Recently leased
Sign in to see leased data
Market data as of 2026-10-12. Sold and leased figures are neighbourhood medians over the last 12 months, published only where at least 5 homes closed — never a single sale.
The honest readPros & cons
What people love
- Affordable median home prices
- Low renter percentage
- Family-friendly environment
- Strong community spirit
Keep in mind
- Limited amenities like restaurants and groceries
- No schools in the area
The feel of the placeLifestyle
Residents enjoy a peaceful life with outdoor activities nearby. It is ideal for those who appreciate nature and community.
Within the boundaryWhat's nearby
The boundary
4.7 km²
Every count and every census figure on this page was measured inside this line — not within a circle drawn around a centre point.
1
Parks
1
Libraries
Counted across all 4.7 km² of Port McNicoll. From OpenStreetMap, as of 2026-10-12.
The peopleWho lives here
2,641
Population (2021)
5.8 km²
Area
458
People per km²
48.8
Median age
$72,857
Median income
87%
Own their home
2.4
People per household
1,105
Households
Every age
- Children (under 15)12.7%
- Working age (15–64)65.9%
- Seniors (65+)21.4%
What is built here
- Detached houses87.4%
- Semi-detached0.5%
- Duplexes2.7%
- Low-rise apartments5.4%
Own or rent
87%Owners
12%Renters
Across 1,105 households
When it was built
Mostly 1960 or earlier
- 1960 or earlier36%
- 1961–198036%
- 1981–19909%
- 1991–20008%
- 2001–20052%
- 2006–20102%
- 2011–20151%
- 2016–20213%
Share of occupied homes, by the era they were built in. Bars are drawn against the busiest era, not against each other, because the eras are not the same length. The eight shares are unlikely to total exactly 100: Statistics Canada rounds each era's count to the nearest 5 before publishing it, so we print what the census reports rather than adjusting a figure to make the column add up.
- 6.4%
- Born outside Canada
- 9.1%
- Hold a degree or higher
- 49.2%
- Employment rate
- 0%
- Commute by transit
- 94.2%
- Commute by car
- 1.5
- Children per family
- $65,244
- Median income after tax
- $81,983
- Average household income
- 11.5%
- Living on a low income
- $1,341/mo
- Renters pay, per month
- $1,052/mo
- Owners pay, per month
- $443,099
- Median home value at census
- 11.3%
- Renters spending 30%+ of income on housing
- 19.6%
- Owners spending 30%+ of income on housing
Statistics Canada, Census of Population 2021. Added up from 5 census areas inside the boundary. Medians and rates are a population-weighted average of dissemination-area figures.
Sources: HOMEH listings, Statistics Canada, Census of Population 2021, OpenStreetMap, Photo: © Wikimedia Commons contributors (CC BY-SA)
What homes in Port McNicoll actually sell for
39 homes changed hands in Port McNicoll over the 12 months to September 2026. Half sold above $452,694 and half below, 5.0% lower than the 12 months before. A typical home found its buyer in 26 days.
- Median sold price
- $453K
- -5.0% year over year
- Days to sell
- 26
- 1 day quicker
- Sales closed
- 39
- last 12 months
- Per square foot
- $452
- from 32 sized sales
Three years of sold prices
The line is the median. The band is the middle half of every sale — how wide it runs tells you how much one home here differs from the next.
What buyers actually paid
$958,600
on a $1,000,000 asking price — under ask by $41,400
- Of the asking price
- 95.9%
- Sold over asking
- 17.9%
From 39 sales that closed here in the last 12 months.
What actually trades in Port McNicoll
A single median hides this: the mix of homes behind it, and what each kind costs.
- Detached$510K17.9%
- Other kinds, too few of each —82.1%
How fast it moves
Median days on market, month by month. Taller means slower.
Terracotta marks the last 12 months.
Every month behind these charts — Port McNicoll, sales
| Month | Closed | Median | Middle half | Days | % of ask |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 2026 | 1 | Not enough sales this month to report a median | |||
| Aug 2026 | 2 | Not enough sales this month to report a median | |||
| Jul 2026 | 7 | $510,000 | $498K – $578K | 16 | 98.6% |
| Jun 2026 | 4 | Not enough sales this month to report a median | |||
| May 2026 | 3 | Not enough sales this month to report a median | |||
| Apr 2026 | 3 | Not enough sales this month to report a median | |||
| Mar 2026 | 3 | Not enough sales this month to report a median | |||
| Feb 2026 | 3 | Not enough sales this month to report a median | |||
| Jan 2026 | 2 | Not enough sales this month to report a median | |||
| Dec 2025 | 4 | Not enough sales this month to report a median | |||
| Nov 2025 | 4 | Not enough sales this month to report a median | |||
| Oct 2025 | 3 | Not enough sales this month to report a median | |||
| Sep 2025 | 4 | Not enough sales this month to report a median | |||
| Aug 2025 | 6 | $477,500 | $414K – $563K | 31 | 97.0% |
| Jul 2025 | 5 | $440,000 | $400K – $500K | 49 | 97.8% |
| Jun 2025 | 6 | $477,500 | $412K – $530K | 13 | 97.7% |
| May 2025 | 3 | Not enough sales this month to report a median | |||
| Apr 2025 | 5 | $459,900 | $250K – $545K | 9 | 100.0% |
| Mar 2025 | 3 | Not enough sales this month to report a median | |||
| Feb 2025 | 3 | Not enough sales this month to report a median | |||
| Jan 2025 | 2 | Not enough sales this month to report a median | |||
| Dec 2024 | 2 | Not enough sales this month to report a median | |||
| Nov 2024 | 7 | $475,000 | $423K – $707K | 18 | 100.0% |
| Oct 2024 | 8 | $585,000 | $70K – $691K | 23 | 94.9% |
| Sep 2024 | 5 | $486,000 | $293K – $700K | 28 | 93.3% |
| Aug 2024 | 8 | $509,950 | $465K – $537K | 44 | 95.5% |
| Jul 2024 | 8 | $563,450 | $520K – $609K | 48 | 99.3% |
| Jun 2024 | 12 | $562,000 | $474K – $617K | 34 | 98.6% |
| May 2024 | 7 | $440,000 | $273K – $485K | 24 | 100.6% |
| Apr 2024 | 4 | Not enough sales this month to report a median | |||
| Mar 2024 | 3 | Not enough sales this month to report a median | |||
| Feb 2024 | 2 | Not enough sales this month to report a median | |||
| Jan 2024 | 2 | Not enough sales this month to report a median | |||
| Dec 2023 | 2 | Not enough sales this month to report a median | |||
| Oct 2023 | 2 | Not enough sales this month to report a median | |||
23 of these months closed fewer than 5 sales. A middle value taken over that few is not a market figure — with one sale it is simply that home's closing price — so the count is shown and the median is not. The sales themselves still count toward the 12-month figures above.
What people ask about Port McNicoll
How much does a home cost in Port McNicoll?
Homes in Port McNicoll sold for a median of $452,694 over the 12 months to September 2026, across 39 closed sales — half sold for more and half for less. That is 5.0% lower than the 12 months before it.
How long does it take to sell a home in Port McNicoll?
A home in Port McNicoll took a median of 26 days on the market over the 12 months to September 2026. Homes there closed at 95.9% of the asking price on average, with 17.9% selling over asking.
Compiled by HOMEH from sales reported closed in Port McNicoll on the Toronto Regional Real Estate Board MLS® System, through September 2026. Medians are taken over closed prices, not asking prices. Per-square-foot figures use the midpoint of the banded floor-area range MLS® carries, so they describe the group and not any one home. Not an appraisal or an opinion of value.