Sold for:Sold May 18, 2026
$409,900

255 Poplar Avenue

Tay (Port McNicoll), ON L0K 1R0

Detached House SoldNot available
Kim Karimi
Kim Karimi

Real Estate Broker

416-838-3031

Property not available for sale or for rent.

Sell with HOMEH

HOMEH One: full-service selling for a 1% listing fee. The buyer's agent commission is separate.

Free Home EvaluationHow Much Is My Home Worth?Homes for Sale Nearby

Sale & Price History for 255 Poplar Avenue, Tay, Port McNicoll

2026-05-13
2026-05-18
Sold
Price
Login to See Prices
MLS#
s13124458

Real estate boards require you to or to see the full details of this property.

*Sold prices and complete sale & price history are regulated data. Under the Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002 (TRESA) and the rules of the Real Estate Council of Ontario (RECO), and pursuant to the Multiple Listing Service® rules of the Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA) and the Toronto Regional Real Estate Board (TRREB), this information may be shown only to registered users who have agreed to the applicable terms of use (a Virtual Office Website, or "VOW," arrangement). HOMEH Inc., Brokerage therefore provides it to signed-in members only. Creating an account is free and takes under a minute.

About 255 Poplar Avenue, Tay, Port McNicoll

Summarized Description

  • Charming detached home in Paradise Point community.
  • Unique antique spiral staircase enhances character.
  • Spacious main floor ideal for entertaining.
  • Bright eat-in kitchen with ample cabinetry.
  • Private lot offers endless outdoor possibilities.
  • Short walk to the waterfront for relaxation.
  • Two well-proportioned bedrooms with peaceful views.
  • Perfect for year-round living or weekend escape.

Welcome to your charming retreat in the highly sought-after Paradise Point community-where lifestyle and location come together beautifully. Set on a generous, private lot, this unique two-storey detached home offers over 1,700 square feet of above-grade living space and an inviting blend of character, warmth, and everyday comfort. From the moment you arrive, you'll appreciate the home's curb appeal and tranquil setting, just a short stroll to the sparkling waterfront. Step inside and discover a spacious main floor designed for relaxed living and effortless entertaining. The oversized living room is the heart of the home, offering abundant natural light, plenty of room for gathering, and a cozy atmosphere perfect for quiet evenings or hosting family and friends. The bright eat-in kitchen provides a welcoming space for everyday meals, featuring generous counter space and ample cabinetry. Adding to the home's unique charm is the stunning antique spiral staircase, a true architectural focal point that beautifully connects the home's two levels and showcases its character-filled design. Upstairs, you'll find two comfortable and well-proportioned bedrooms, each offering peaceful views and a relaxing retreat at the end of the day. The home is thoughtfully designed with one and a half bathrooms, providing convenience for both residents and guests. Outside, the expansive lot offers endless possibilities. Whether you dream of creating a garden oasis, outdoor entertaining area, or simply enjoying the privacy and space, this property delivers the freedom to make it your own. Imagine morning walks to the water, sunset strolls along the shoreline, and the serenity of lakeside living just steps from your door. Perfect for year-round living or a weekend escape, this offers charm, space, and an unbeatable lifestyle opportunity in a truly special setting. Some photos have been virtually stagged.

Key Facts & Features

Property Costs

Annual Property Tax Amount
$1,920
Land Transfer Tax Fee
$4,673

Rental Items

Rental Equipment
None
Under Contract
None

Basement Type
None

Interior Features

Laundry Level
Main Level
Interior Extras
Water Heater Owned
Fireplace/Stove
No
Elevator
No

Exterior Features

Exterior Extras
Year Round Living
Pool
None

Building

Building Type
Detached
Building Style
2-Storey
Approx Age
51-99

Construction

Exterior Finish
Brick
Roof
Asphalt Shingle
Foundation Details
Concrete
Special Designation
Unknown

Lot

Lot Front
114.21 ft
Lot Depth
146.53 ft
Lot Shape
Rectangular

Inclusions

Inclusions
Fridge, stove, dishwasher, washer, dryer, hot water heater, window air conditioner (all appliances are "as is"), central vac, garden shed, all existing window coverings

Parking & Garages

Garage Type
None
Garage Spaces
0
Parking Spaces
3
Total Garage And Parking Spaces
3

Heating & Cooling

Heat Source
Electric
Heat Type
Baseboard
Air Conditioning
Window Unit(s)
Water
Both
Sewers
Septic

Bedrooms
2
Washrooms
2
Kitchens
1

Washrooms

  • 4-piece, Second
  • 2-piece, Main

Municipality
Tay
Neighbourhood
Port McNicoll
Main cross streets
Limestone Road and Poplar Avenue
Zoning
R2-16(H)
Directions
1st Ave, to Limestone to Poplar

MLS® number
S13124458
Data source
Toronto Regional Real Estate Board
Status change
2026-05-18
Listed on
2026-05-13
Days on market
5 days
Possession type
Immediate
Co-op commission
2.5% (less 1% if LA shows home)
Seller
Listed by
RE/MAX HALLMARK CHAY REALTY

Home Market Value

Current home valuation for 255 Poplar Avenue, Tay, Port McNicoll, Tay, ON. Listed for $409,900

HOMEH Estimate

?

$449,017

Estimated Sales Range

?

$314,312 - $583,722

HOMEH Estimate for 255 Poplar Avenue, Tay, Port McNicoll

Calculated with a real agent's CMA method — 45+ years of experience, codified. Not an AI guess.

$449,017Low confidence
Based on 6 comparable properties
See the full analysisFree Every recent nearby sale behind this number

For the owner

Is this your home? Track its value.

Get this home's HOMEH Estimate by email once a month, with how many homes are for sale around you.

Mortgage Payment Calculator

Compare up to 4 down payment scenarios

$
Tay, ON
Minimum Down Payment Required:5.0%

5% of purchase price for homes $500K or less

Minimum down payment

$20,495

Scenario 1 Scenario 2 Scenario 3 Scenario 4
−Down payment
%
$
%
$
%
$
%
$
+CMHC insurance
$15,576$11,436$9,756$0
=Total mortgage
$404,981$380,346$358,171$327,920
Amortization
Mortgage rate
%
%
%
%
Payment frequency
=Mortgage payment
$1,977monthly$1,857monthly$1,749monthly$1,601monthly
Are you a first time home buyer?

Land Transfer Tax

Provincial

$4,673

Total Land Transfer Tax

$4,673

Around this home

0/100Almost All Errands Require a Car
0/100Minimal Transit
0/100Not rated
Loading map...

No schools found nearby

Ask HOMEH

New!
H

Hi there!

👋

Text or call (416) 301-9001

Recommended for you

Based on homes you've looked at.

No recommended properties found.

Nearby similar homes

No nearby properties found.