Front of 269 Sugarloaf Street

269 Sugarloaf Street

Port Colborne (Sugarloaf)
Detached Terminated
1/41
Front of 269 Sugarloaf Street

269 Sugarloaf Street

Port Colborne (Sugarloaf)
Detached Terminated
Photo 2 of 41 – 269 Sugarloaf Street, Port ColbornePhoto 3 of 41 – 269 Sugarloaf Street, Port ColbornePhoto 4 of 41 – 269 Sugarloaf Street, Port ColbornePhoto 5 of 41 – 269 Sugarloaf Street, Port ColborneSee all 41 photos
Last asked:Terminated Apr 19, 2025
3+2 Bedrooms
3 Bathrooms
2 Garage
1.5K–2K sq.ft
47.5×160 ft
$3,481/yr

Property history

  1. $749,000TerminatedList: 2024-07-04End: 2025-04-19289 daysX9408410
  2. $799,000TerminatedList: 2024-05-10End: 2025-04-19344 daysX8492309

Facts and features

  • BasementFinished
  • Price per sq ft~$457
  • Water, sewerMunicipal
  • ExposureNorth
What stands out
  • Central air
The homeDetached, 2-storey, 1,500–2,000 sq ft
  • Type: Detached
  • Style: 2-storey
  • Living space: 1,500–2,000 sq ft
  • Basement: Finished, full
  • Exposure: North
  • Waterfront: None
InsideUpgraded insulation, water heater owned, central vacuum, Rooms above ground 10, Rooms in the basement 3
  • Features: Upgraded insulation, water heater owned, central vacuum
Rooms
  • Rooms above ground: 10
  • Rooms in the basement: 3
  • Bedrooms: 3 + 2 in the basement
  • Bathrooms: 3
  • Kitchens: 1
Outside and lotAluminum siding, vinyl siding, Asphalt shingle, Concrete block
Outside
  • Exterior: Aluminum siding, vinyl siding
  • Roof: Asphalt shingle
  • Foundation: Concrete block
  • Features: Deck, porch
Lot
  • Size: 47.5 × 160 ft
  • Zoning: R2
Parking2 Garage, Detached, Private, reserved/assigned
  • Spaces: 2 Garage
  • Garage: Detached
  • Driveway: Private, reserved/assigned
Heating, water and powerForced air, gas, Central air, Municipal water
  • Heating: Forced air, gas
  • Cooling: Central air
  • Water: Municipal water
  • Sewer: Municipal sewer
Costs and taxesTaxes $3,481 a year
  • Taxes, 2023: $3,481 a year
Included in the saleCentral vacuum, dishwasher, dryer, furniture, microwave, negotiable, rangehood, refrigerator, stove, washer, hot water tank owned, window coverings
  • Included: Central vacuum, dishwasher, dryer, furniture, microwave, negotiable, rangehood, refrigerator, stove, washer, hot water tank owned, window coverings
NearbyGolf, hospital, fenced yard
  • Close to: Golf, hospital, fenced yard
Listing detailsX8492309, Terminated, May 10, 2024
  • MLS® number: X8492309
  • Status: Terminated
  • Listed on: May 10, 2024
  • Days on market: 344
  • Updated: Apr 19, 2025
  • Possession: Immediate
  • Occupied by: Vacant
  • Listing brokerage: REVEL Realty Inc., Brokerage

About this home

269 Sugarloaf Street, Port Colborne (Sugarloaf), ON L3K 2P1

Upgraded InsulationWater Heater OwnedCentral VacuumGolfHospitalFenced Yard

Welcome to 269 Sugarloaf Street, Port Colborne - a delightful abode affectionately known as "Sugarloaf." This fully furnished charming two-storey historic mill house, dating back to 1912, underwent a meticulous renovation in 2012, overseen by a dedicated live-in contractor who poured passion into every corner of Sugarloaf's restoration. This century home boasts a rich architectural heritage, showcasing original features such as stained glass windows, intricate baseboards, Colonial window casings, and crown moldings. With five bedrooms, Sugarloaf offers a cozy retreat for all. Step inside to discover a traditional dining room, a spacious family room adorned with custom hardwood detailing, and eat-in kitchen complete with an adjacent mudroom and a convenient 3-piece bath. Upstairs, three bedrooms await, along with a luxurious family bath featuring the original claw foot tub and an adjoining laundry room. The partially finished basement adds versatility with two additional bedrooms, a two-piece bath. The front porch, nestled behind a quaint cobblestone walkway and shaded by a majestic Century Tulip tree—a perfect spot to unwind and enjoy the tranquility. A sprawling wrap around deck, ideal for gatherings. This idyllic locale on Sugarloaf Street embodies the quintessential Lake Erie lifestyle, offering easy access to Sugarloaf Harbour Marina, H.H. Knoll Lakeview Park, and pristine beaches just minutes away. Walk downtown or indulge in Canal Days festival, canal-side strolls, restaurants. Additional features include a new furnace installed 2022, and a newly owned hot water tank as of 2024. With the option for immediate occupancy, this turnkey gem presents a rare opportunity to embrace the essence of Lake Erie living year-round. Words cannot capture the true essence of Sugarloaf—its allure must be experienced firsthand. Don't miss your chance to make this enchanting retreat your own and embark on a journey of timeless charm and coastal bliss.

Ask about this home

A HOMEH agent will answer your questions about this home.

Ask a question
Thinking of selling your home?See what your home is worth today.

Around this home

Steele street to Sugarlof Street
87Errands
97Parks
86Schools

Daily convenience, out of 100, from the distances below

ParkHH Knoll Lakeview Park · 2 within 1 km5 min walk336 m
GroceryFood Basics11 min walk649 m
SchoolSteele Street Public School8 min walk470 m
PharmacyMy Pharmacy12 min walk753 m
Cafés & foodDawg's Burgers & Fries · 13 within 1 km7 min walk423 m
Gym & rec centreG&M Fitness15 min walk937 m
LibraryPort Colborne Public Library16 min walk997 m
HospitalPort Colborne Complex and Urgent Care Centre3 min walk184 m
WalkDriveStraight-line distance, open map data
Grocery0.6 km
Park0.3 km
Coffee0.9 km
Dining0.8 km
Gym0.9 km
Hospital0.2 km

Schools nearby

School rating, out of 10.

Steele Street Public Schoolelementary · Public · 0.5 km
5.9/10Fair
Port Colborne High Schoolsecondary · Public · 0.9 km
6.5/10Good
St Patrick Catholic Elementary Schoolelementary · Catholic · 1.1 km
—
Contact agent

Helpful calculators

Mortgage
Affordability
Closing costs
Land transfer tax
Property tax
Down payment
CMHC insurance
Stress test
Cashback Rebate

Your HOMEH agent

KimHOMEH agent · Port Colborne

"Priced 35% over the Hestimate. I would see it this week."

Ask Kim

© 2026 HOMEH Inc., Brokerage · RECO Registration #6000380 · 505 Highway 7 East, Unit 308, Thornhill, ON L3T 7T1 · Listing data courtesy of the MLS® System of the listing brokerage, deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Disclaimers and terms

* Hestimate. HOMEH's estimate of this home's value, from recent sales and current market data; it may change over time.

HOMEH is operated by HOMEH Inc., a licensed Ontario real estate brokerage regulated by the Real Estate Council of Ontario (RECO) under the Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002 (TRESA). Under TRESA, consumers are entitled to the RECO Information Guide before entering into a representation agreement. Broker of Record Licence #5034208. Toronto Regional Real Estate Board Member #20004000.

Cashback Rebate. Paid by HOMEH Inc., Brokerage from the commission it receives, on closing, to eligible buyers who came to HOMEH as HOMEH leads. Subject to the buyer representation agreement, lender approval and legal limits; amounts vary with price, commission received and transaction type. Not a government incentive, tax credit or refund. Full terms and conditions apply.

Mortgage. Payment figures are estimates for illustration only, not an offer to lend; all financing is on approved credit (OAC). HOMEH Inc., Brokerage is not a mortgage broker, agent or lender; mortgage products and advice come from independent professionals licensed by the Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario (FSRA).

Hestimate. Worked out with automated tools from recent nearby sales of similar homes. For information only, not an appraisal.

Accuracy. Listings, market data, photos, school, transit and neighbourhood information come from sources believed reliable, including the MLS® System and the Toronto Regional Real Estate Board (TRREB), but are not warranted accurate, current or complete. MLS® listing data is copyright TRREB. It must only be used by consumers with a bona fide interest in the purchase, sale or lease of real estate, and not for any commercial purpose.

Programs. Programs, incentives and benefits on this website are privately administered, may change or end without notice, and imply no government authority, endorsement or affiliation.

Not intended to solicit clients currently under contract with another brokerage.

The trademarks REALTOR®, REALTORS® and the REALTOR® logo are controlled by The Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA) and identify real estate professionals who are members of CREA. The trademarks MLS®, Multiple Listing Service® and the associated logos are owned by CREA and identify the quality of services provided by real estate professionals who are members of CREA. Used under licence.