440 Coney Island

Ultimate Privacy and Multi-Lot Potential: 12.3-Acre Waterfront Retreat. Discover an exceptional, ultra-private waterfront sanctuary located just minutes from town. This beautifully maintained estate offers unparalleled seclusion, a pristine sand beach, and spectacular northwestern exposure for unforgettable sunset views. Adding immense investment value, the property includes three individual property titles bundled into a single sale. The turn-key estate features a meticulously kept 1,024 sq. ft. 2-bedroom main residence, a charming separate guest cottage, and a single-stall boathouse—all completely ready for immediate enjoyment. Built to stand the test of time and flawlessly maintained, the main cottage features new shingles installed in 2025. You can turn the key and start relaxing on day one while enjoying the rare convenience of seasonal municipal (city) water service paired with a fully functional septic system and a cozy woodstove for cooler seasons. This property offers year-round appeal, from serene summer days on the sand beach to unique, convenient winter access right across the ice. Because this estate consists of three distinct lots with three individual titles, you hold a wealth of options: keep the entirety as a massive, ultra-private family compound, or explore the exceptional potential to develop additional cottages. It places you minutes from town, yet a world away from the noise. Don't miss out on this pristine piece of waterfront paradise! Great spot on the south shore of Safety Bay, Coney Island. Minutes to town!